options trading / data analysis / stock market
Do You Need Decades of Market Data?
A commenter said my NVIDIA puts analysis was weak because it used only four years of market data and should have used a Black-Scholes model. Here's why I disagree. Black-Scholes is a model and doesn't fully match how real options price. More importantly, the market of 20 years ago was a different regime: you called a broker and paid commissions, while today anyone can download an app and trade options in 20 minutes, alongside prediction markets, Robinhood and AI trading. I'm not claiming my analysis is the strongest possible, but recent data is the most relevant.
Transcript
0:00A lot of people insist that you need decades and decades of historical financial data to perform a strong analysis
0:07Here's why I think that's very short sighted For context I posted my video on how the
0:12NVIDIA CEO had an affair with an alleged Chinese spy and this is why
0:17NVIDIA is down 5 today I looked at historical market data for
0:22NVIDIA and saw that if you bought puts after the news broke you're more likely than not to lose a bunch of money
0:31The analysis primarily uses the median of returns It shows that pretty much no matter what put you buy you're going to lose money on it
0:39This comment's critique is that because I've only used the last four years of market data the analysis isn't very strong and that I should have
0:47instead implemented the Black-Scholes model This is short sighted for several reasons
0:53Number one the Black-Scholes model is just that It's a model
0:57It doesn't 100 accurately represent what options actually price at
1:02For a stock like NVIDIA it's more accurate but it's still not entirely accurate
1:08It doesn't account for a lot of things that happen with real world options
1:11Number two and most importantly you're assuming the stock market 20 years ago is relevant
1:18You're assuming that when back in the day when you wanted to make a trade you had to call a broker on the phone to make
1:24your trades and pay five bucks in commissions You assume that market regime is similar to what it is now where anybody can download one of
1:34a dozen apps and start trading options in less than 20 minutes
1:39The overall structure of the market is fundamentally different With things like prediction markets
1:45Robinhood and AI trading it's just not relevant to look at 20 years ago
1:52Hell actually no market data is really relevant because anything can happen
1:58I'm not claiming I created the strongest analysis possible but I am claiming it's a pretty decent analysis
2:04If you lose your money
2:11will it lose you money this time
2:14I personally think yes but follow to see what play I actually do and the data analysis behind it
Join the conversation
Loading conversation…